Skip to content

Human vs Perfect Morse

A machine sends the ratios exactly. Nobody else does. This plays the same word both ways and draws both timings, so you can see what your ear is struggling with.

 

Machine
Hand

Press the two buttons one after the other. The bars underneath show the same two transmissions on the same scale - the top one is what the textbook says, the bottom one is what a hand produces.

Why perfect Morse is the wrong thing to train on

Every training tool sends perfectly, and that is a problem. On the air, almost nobody does. An operator who has only ever heard machine timing hears their first real signal and finds it unreadable - not because it is too fast, but because it is uneven.

What actually varies:

  • Dash length. Should be three dots. In practice it runs between two and four, and it drifts within a single transmission.
  • Dot evenness. A tired hand produces dots of visibly different length, and the ear starts guessing where the dashes begin.
  • Letter gaps. The most common fault by far, and the most damaging: a gap that is too short does not garble a letter, it produces a different letter.
  • Speed drift. Not jitter but a slow wander, usually accelerating towards the end of a transmission as the sender relaxes.

Reading the two bars

Both bars are drawn on the same scale, so they can be compared directly. Filled blocks are tone, gaps are silence, and the width is the duration - not the count.

That last point matters. If the widths were equal, a short dash and a correct dash would look identical, and the picture would show nothing. Because the width follows the time, a dash that runs at twice a dot instead of three times is visibly stubbier, and you can point at it.

Look at the silences as much as the tones. Half of what makes real Morse hard is in the gaps, and the gaps are where the eye finds it faster than the ear.

The five hands

  • Beginner - slow, short dashes, hesitant gaps. Sounds laboured because it is.
  • Shaky hand - the elements land all over the place. Hardest of the five, and common among operators who are cold or tired.
  • Deliberate - slow but clean. Easier to read than a fast sloppy hand, which is the whole argument for slowing down.
  • Practised - close to the machine, with just enough variation to sound human.
  • Contest speed - fast and tight, with letter gaps trimmed. Legible only if you are already fluent.

Compare Deliberate against Contest speed at the same setting. The slow one is nearly always easier to copy, and that is the finding worth taking away.

What to do with it

Two things.

First, train against imperfect sending, not just perfect. The error simulator takes this further: it sends one fault at a time and asks you to name it.

Second, listen to your own hand. The sending practice measures what you actually produce - and most people are surprised by their dash ratio the first time they see it.

Frequently asked questions

  • Why does perfect Morse sound different?

    Because it holds the ratios exactly: a dash is precisely three dots, every gap is exact. No hand does that, and the ear notices immediately.

  • Which fault matters most?

    Letter gaps. A gap that is too short does not blur a letter, it turns it into a different one - and often a real one, so the result looks plausible and is wrong.

  • Should I train at speed or at accuracy?

    Accuracy. Compare the deliberate hand against contest speed here: the slow clean one is easier to copy than the fast tight one, every time.